The brownies were delicious! Money well spent and Buckeye brownies will be seeing from me again! Thank you for the amazing gourmet brownies
Subscriber pricing applies to every order for as long as you stay subscribed. Full price becomes a thing of the past.
Everything we make is baked to order, so a regular reorder waits in a 4-7 day bake line. Your subscription starts the next bake automatically, and the box lands before the craving does.
Swap flavors, switch products, change your delivery date, or skip a cycle right from your account. Rotate through the whole lineup one box at a time.
Point a subscription at someone else’s door and become their favorite person on a schedule. Birthdays end. This doesn’t.
THE ULTIMATE SUBSCRIPTION
Enjoy a brand new lineup of 4 limited edition gourmet brownies straight to your door every single month, packed with our most exclusive flavors, nostalgic creations, and specialty drops you won’t find anywhere else.
🚀 FREE Rush Baking on Every Order ($10 Value)
🛍️ 10% Off Subscriber Discount
📦 Free Exclusive Gifts on orders starting Month 2
Go with the Box of the Month for new flavors every month, or subscribe to the favorites you already love like our Fantastic Four Pack, Fudge Cups, Cookie Cakes & much more!
Select the Subscribe & Save option on the product page and watch 10% come off instantly.
Every subscription runs on a monthly rhythm, timed so your stash never runs dry. Need a breather? Skip a month from your account in a few taps.
Every order is baked fresh in Akron, Ohio when your ship date comes up. Brownies, cookies, cakes, or fudge cups, it all lands at your door without you lifting a finger.
You’ve seen our math before: one 4-pack holds around 4 pounds of brownie, which stacks up to roughly 16 normal-sized brownies.
Subscribe to the Fantastic Four Pack at $32.40 and that works out to about $2.03 per brownie. You get the same half-pound heavyweights with the same three layers, baked fresh for less than a gas station brownie that’s been sitting there since Tuesday.
Cookies, cakes, and fudge cups get the same 10% treatment.
Overall rating: 4.6 / 5 from 21754 reviews.
The brownies were delicious! Money well spent and Buckeye brownies will be seeing from me again! Thank you for the amazing gourmet brownies
Great wrk
Amazingly quick shipping! Worth every penny! The new birthday cake choice for my teenager! 😋⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️😁
Me and a co-work decided to go half on this. Both of us got milk & cookies. This was the best one for sure!
They were outrageously delicious
I would have sent a picture and/or video had I received this sooner….Everything was gone in two days… Shared with friends….VERY, VERY GOOD 😁 THANK YOU
The driver was friendly
This was an AMAZING brownie. All of the brownies are superb, but i have my favorites. This may be a new one
Excellent
As long as you either don't heat these things up at all - or maybe don't heat them too much (the frosting surface will become hard) - these things are AMAZING. I've spent maybe around $200 in recent months on Buckeyes Brownies cookie cakes and brownies and I've had great experiences life-wise involving them, but taste-wise they're more often okay (Oreo Cookie Cake - if you get the heating right though, this can be AMAZING I found on one or more points within eating on my second time ordering this; maybe their heating instructions would've covered this, but otherwise I think waiting until it cools down WELL and almost back to base temperature may be important) or disappointing (ultimate cookie cake) or good/great in a WAY (Red Velvet) and for a lot of money. It might be really important to listen to their heating instructions, but still. Their stuff isn't as great as the ads make it seem. This specific treat is perhaps the only thing so far in my personal experience that's of that caliber. I guess my brownie cake experience of the "Gift" was good (for most of it). That might be up there. There might be other things that I've tasted or not tasted - but overall this might be the best contender for the level of dopeness you'd expect from those commercials.
Bought it for niece and her new college roommates... they're over the moon!
Chips Ahoy and Oreo, what more can you ask for? Just loved this combination, glad I bought 2 boxes.
Was very good. I ordered another in my next order. This is the first duplicate item ordered so far.
Absolutely delicious. I just placed another order this morning.
Very good and for the price it is a steal
APPLEY EVRR AFTER....OMG!!!! They are prerfect. Delivery was great and these brownies are huge. You got another order coming your way. THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!!!
I would have liked a more tangy strawberry flavor but other than that, it was PERFECT
Very fresh and tasty!
This one was my favorite
The brownies did not disappoint! They were all great!
I really enjoyed the brownies. They were somehow even bigger than I expected (I compared them to my sandwich, and they were as wide as one, but thicker than one, as well), but cutting them up and splitting them amongst friends and family helped. The taste of this combination was interesting, and I really liked how they blended together. I would definitely recommend these brownies to people in my life.
All gone
As always the brownies were great. I loved the summer flavors. Not big on fruit flavors and the strawberry was outstanding. What a great surprise. Thanks so much. Can’t wait to see the fall flavors.
Great company Delicious product
Love then im obsessed!! Lol
Taste amazing
Hugeeee brownies 😋
this box gets you ready Thanksgiving the way it's packed with flavor
Excellent Delivery!
I love your brownies they are so thick and delicious. Only problem for me is I’m diabetic so I have to eat them in moderation. Thank you Michael Daniels
Everything is so delicious
They were absolutely amazing
Those were amazing. They are gone. Need to get more of them soon
I am still working on the others but the almond Joy one was good
👍👍
A wonderful bonus of the monthly subscription box is that we get a surprise gift with each shipment. What a surprise when I realized the plate is ceramic, not plastic and the silverware is metal. The silverware has Buckeye Brownies imprinted on them.
I just love, love, love my Buckeye Brownie subscription. I can't wait for the box to arrive each month. This month, The Fall Favorites, I particularly enjoyed Mr. Tuxedo and Appley Ever After.
It was amazing
All of the brownies were amazing!
I love them
Subscribing keeps your freezer stocked and your wallet happier, with zero effort on your end. Here’s everything that comes with it:
10% off, always: subscriber pricing on every single order, for as long as you’re in.
Never miss a drop: the Box of the Month automatically includes each month’s 4 limited-edition flavors before they retire.
Free rush baking ($10 value): Box of the Month orders skip the 4 to 7 day bake line.
Free gifts from month 2: exclusive extras land in your box starting your second month.
Never run out: your favorites show up on schedule without you lifting a finger.
Over 20 of our delicious desserts & counting!
The Brownie Box of the Month plus every evergreen favorite: the Fantastic Four Pack, The MVP, Mr. Buckeye, The Gift, Snickerdoodle & Chill, both cookie cakes, the Classics fudge cups and bundle, Buckeye Bombs, Grandma’s cookies, and the full gluten-free and vegan lineup.
Seasonal boxes are only around while their month lasts, and the Box of the Month is how you get every one of them automatically.
Your box automatically contains the 4 flavors of the month, baked fresh and shipped with free rush baking.
Flavors rotate monthly and retire when the month ends, so subscribers get every drop without lifting a finger.
Your subscription runs a 2-month minimum, then you manage everything from your account.
Yes, it's super simple! Just log in to your account to swap products, adjust your delivery schedule, skip a month, or cancel.
The Box of the Month asks for a 2-month minimum before cancellation; evergreen product subscriptions can be adjusted anytime.
Everything is baked fresh to order. Standard orders take 4 to 7 days in the bakery plus transit time. Box Of The Month subscribers jump the queue with free rush baking. Your desserts stay fresh in transit and freeze beautifully for up to 3 months.
Standard shipping rates apply, and orders over $100 ship free.
Reach the team anytime at support@buckeyebrownies.com and we'll get you sorted.
