Appreciated the Rush Baking option!!
Subscriber pricing applies to every order for as long as you stay subscribed. Full price becomes a thing of the past.
Everything we make is baked to order, so a regular reorder waits in a 4-7 day bake line. Your subscription starts the next bake automatically, and the box lands before the craving does.
Swap flavors, switch products, change your delivery date, or skip a cycle right from your account. Rotate through the whole lineup one box at a time.
Point a subscription at someone else’s door and become their favorite person on a schedule. Birthdays end. This doesn’t.
THE ULTIMATE SUBSCRIPTION
Enjoy a brand new lineup of 4 limited edition gourmet brownies straight to your door every single month, packed with our most exclusive flavors, nostalgic creations, and specialty drops you won’t find anywhere else.
🚀 FREE Rush Baking on Every Order ($10 Value)
🛍️ 10% Off Subscriber Discount
📦 Free Exclusive Gifts on orders starting Month 2
Go with the Box of the Month for new flavors every month, or subscribe to the favorites you already love like our Fantastic Four Pack, Fudge Cups, Cookie Cakes & much more!
Select the Subscribe & Save option on the product page and watch 10% come off instantly.
Every subscription runs on a monthly rhythm, timed so your stash never runs dry. Need a breather? Skip a month from your account in a few taps.
Every order is baked fresh in Akron, Ohio when your ship date comes up. Brownies, cookies, cakes, or fudge cups, it all lands at your door without you lifting a finger.
You’ve seen our math before: one 4-pack holds around 4 pounds of brownie, which stacks up to roughly 16 normal-sized brownies.
Subscribe to the Fantastic Four Pack at $32.40 and that works out to about $2.03 per brownie. You get the same half-pound heavyweights with the same three layers, baked fresh for less than a gas station brownie that’s been sitting there since Tuesday.
Cookies, cakes, and fudge cups get the same 10% treatment.
Overall rating: 4.6 / 5 from 21488 reviews.
Appreciated the Rush Baking option!!
These were a gift and as it turned out, he had tried them previously. But it was ok because he had different flavors. They were a big hit!
Great brownies, we love them!
best brownies ever!!! amazing customer service as well. everything you buy is worth it 🔥
delicious
.
I am SO glad I decided to purchase from Brownies because I will definitely be coming back for more! They are absolutely delicious!!! 🤤 And let me tell you—pop one in the oven at 350° for about 5–10 minutes, and it becomes soft, warm, and downright heavenly. Chef’s kiss! 😘👌 Consider me a forever fan! ❤️🍫
Worth it if you are running low on your favorite brownies but they give you rush baking as part of a monthly subscription.
Out of this world, mate. They were such a great cheat meal. Shared with my coworkers and they loved it. Ordering again coming this winter break :D
Great flavor. By far my absolute favorite. Highly recommend.
Love them
I took these to my former coworkers to share with them. Everyone really liked them. I brought the rest of them home with me and love them heated up in the microwave.
This is just half a Oreo magical ooey gooey delicious yumminess brownie. Sooooooo good. Zero regrets. Just a few calories!!! Shhhh just hit the gym after it's worth it.
Chocolatey, salty peanut butter. Great combo. Instructions say to store your goodies in the fridge, but eating them straight out of the fridge yields and sweet and not very flavorful treat. Let it come to room temp, or microwave it for just a few seconds until the middle is warm and it will transform it to a delicious pastry.
The best by far
Cookies were soft, chewy, and delicious!
It was protection.
They were very good. I will order again.
Love these sweets, and customer support was great! 😁
Looks taste and feel like a home cooked chocolate chip cookie.
I ordered 3 orders of the same selection for 3 different people. None of them had ever tried buckeye brownies. They were astounded at their size one ate the peanut butter brownie in their order and the other person in their order ate the snickerdoodle brownie. 100% thumbs up and both chose to freeze the remaining 3 for another time. As for the 3rd order that would be for me and I froze all 4 brownies to contribute as a dessert for a group trip in September.
Amazing
The Oatmeal Cream Pie was my absolute favorite! 🤎 It was so delicious, and even better with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top. Definitely a must-try! 🍦😍
Absolutely loved the Strawberry Cheesecake Brownie! 🍓🍰 It was so moist and delicious, and definitely even better served warm. I would 100% buy it again! 😋
I ate them so fast forgot the pic/video!! Soooo good!!!!!
Very good, my second favorite in the box i had
Incredible ! One of the best flavors. Very moist and so much flavor!
Delicious brownies I loved the variety in the flavors. They filled me up every time, and I will definitely be buying from them again. And the cookies are amazing I shared them with my friends and it had them wondering where I got them from.
Everything in the box was absolutely amazing! It was a gift that was much appreciated!
We ate the entire box like usual! It’s a great treat for the whole work crew and or family to enjoy.
Flavors were great, just a little dry. Still an enjoyable experience
Awesome
Ok
The Great White was my favorite out of the whole box. I’m a sucker for snickerdoodle and The Great White still edged it out which sings very high praises to the combination in that blondie!
Amazing
It was delicious
This one was wonderful was my favorite out of the four I ordered if you like peanut butter this is your jam!!!!
Definitely the best brownies out there. I’ve been eating em for years. They will without a doubt satisfy any sweet tooth 🤗❤️
As usual, the order went fine/smooth. Also, as usual, the cookies were soft, moist and tasty. Totally happy with this purchase.
Not over powerful coconut taste and very good and tasty.
Subscribing keeps your freezer stocked and your wallet happier, with zero effort on your end. Here’s everything that comes with it:
10% off, always: subscriber pricing on every single order, for as long as you’re in.
Never miss a drop: the Box of the Month automatically includes each month’s 4 limited-edition flavors before they retire.
Free rush baking ($10 value): Box of the Month orders skip the 4 to 7 day bake line.
Free gifts from month 2: exclusive extras land in your box starting your second month.
Never run out: your favorites show up on schedule without you lifting a finger.
Over 20 of our delicious desserts & counting!
The Brownie Box of the Month plus every evergreen favorite: the Fantastic Four Pack, The MVP, Mr. Buckeye, The Gift, Snickerdoodle & Chill, both cookie cakes, the Classics fudge cups and bundle, Buckeye Bombs, Grandma’s cookies, and the full gluten-free and vegan lineup.
Seasonal boxes are only around while their month lasts, and the Box of the Month is how you get every one of them automatically.
Your box automatically contains the 4 flavors of the month, baked fresh and shipped with free rush baking.
Flavors rotate monthly and retire when the month ends, so subscribers get every drop without lifting a finger.
Your subscription runs a 2-month minimum, then you manage everything from your account.
Yes, it's super simple! Just log in to your account to swap products, adjust your delivery schedule, skip a month, or cancel.
The Box of the Month asks for a 2-month minimum before cancellation; evergreen product subscriptions can be adjusted anytime.
Everything is baked fresh to order. Standard orders take 4 to 7 days in the bakery plus transit time. Box Of The Month subscribers jump the queue with free rush baking. Your desserts stay fresh in transit and freeze beautifully for up to 3 months.
Standard shipping rates apply, and orders over $100 ship free.
Reach the team anytime at support@buckeyebrownies.com and we'll get you sorted.
