Buckeye Brownies

Mr Buckeye 4-Pack

Sale price Price $30.00 Regular price Unit price  per 

Not all heroes wear capes! Because whoever decided to combine chocolate with peanut butter is an absolute genius! Meet, Mr Buckeye.

This decadent dessert first starts with our fudge brownie base which is then layered with none other than some of the best peanut butter cookies on the market, Nutter Butters.

We then topped it all with our homemade Reeses Pieces cookie dough. Although it looked great, it didn’t reach the standard yet.

This is why we sprinkled some more Reeses Pieces on top and added another peanut butter cookie to really balance out that chocolate peanut butter ratio.

So If your heart melts at all things chocolate-peanut butter, we can promise that this is the brownie for you!

*Processed in a facility that also works with peanuts, wheat, dairy, and soy.*

*If brownies are desired to arrive on a specific date, please order at least a week in advance due to the influx of orders.*


Refrigerate upon arrival. Keep them in the refrigerator so they stay intact. You can either take them out and either eat cold or warm them up in the microwave for 5-10 seconds if you want them to taste as if they came right out of the oven.

Not planning on eating within 7 days upon arrival? Throw them in the freezer to ensure their moistness. Let them defrost when ready to be consumed.


Shop Brownies Online Here

Customer Reviews

Based on 14 reviews

These tasted ok, not great but not bad. They were however, surprisingly dry. I wouldn’t buy them again.

Dugan Brink

They taste so good the kids went crazy for them, we will definitely be ordering them again

Robert Tevins
Quite tasty

It was really good( honestly) . I wish my new order came in as fast as my first tho 😔

Christopher Lassalle
Yummy Brownies

I loved the Mr Buckeye Brownies I got last time and now I’m going to enjoy some chocolate chip cookies and March Madness Brownies next!!!!