Buckeye Brownies

Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack - LAST CALL

Sale price Price $38.00 Regular price $40.00 Unit price  per 

Love is in the air and it’s time to show some affection and care! This month is all about treating your loved ones or simply treating YO SELF!

What better way to do just that than by indulging in our Limited Edition Valentines Flavors!

This brand new box comes with one of each of our four new flavors including Strawberry Sensation, Hella Nutella, Butterfinger AF and Circus Animal.

Only available until the 23rd so you better stock up while you can!


Roses are red, violets are blue, we think chocolate and strawberries make the PERFECT pair, how about you?

Introducing, Strawberry Sensation.

This festive, limited edition flavor first starts with our buttery blondie base which is then layered with none other than a frosted strawberry poptart.

We then created a strawberry jam inspired cookie dough to bring that authentic strawberry taste and infused it with tons of chocolate chips!

But we couldn’t stop there!

Which is why we decided to top it all with our homemade sugar crumb topping, more chocolate chips along with a dash of turbinado cane sugar.

Who needs chocolate covered strawberries this Valentine’s Day when you can dive into Strawberry Sensation?!


Rich, Thick, and Volumptuous. Three things we all want in life right? Well, we wanted to create a flavor that perfectly fit those criteria, especially for the month of love!

Introducing, Hella Nutella.

The nutty chocolate inspiration first starts with our fudge brownie base which is then layered with an abundance of chocolate hazelnut Oreos.

We then topped it all with our Nutella infused, hazelnut chocolate chip themed cookie dough.

But we had to make it HELLA delicious!

So we decided to top it all with crushed hazelnuts, broken up Chocolate Hazelnut Oreos and perfected it with a Nutella drizzle after the bake.

Are YOU ready to dive into Hella Nutella this February?


What happens when you combine an Iconic candy along with a gourmet baked dessert?

You get something special. You get something satisfying. You get our latest and greatest flavor yet.

Introducing, Butterfinger AF.

This Limited Edition Valentines flavor is created exactly how it sounds, with a ton of butterfingers! But let’s break it down.

This slice of greatness first starts with our famous fudge brownie base which is then layered with peanut butter fudge tagalong cookies.

We then concocted a unique Butterfinger themed cookie dough and infused it with tons crushed Butterfinger.

After the bake, we perfected this bad boy by sprinkling it with some more crushed Butterfinger and added an actual snack-size Butterfinger on top.

Let’s just say this is one nutty treat that you won’t wanna let slip through your hands this month!

**The Butterfinger on top is subject to melting during shipment.**


Ladies and Gentlemen, Boys and Girls, Children of all ages…

Be prepared for something truly special, something so marvelous and spectacular that your eyes won’t be able to look away.

Introducing, Circus Animal.

This one of a kind delight first starts with our buttery blondie base and is then layered with none other than tons of frosted animal cookies.

We then topped it all with our homemade funfetti cake cookie dough, infused it with white chips and sprinkles and threw it in the oven!

But that simply wasn’t exciting enough! So we added more white chips, a few more animal crackers and some sprinkles to really set the stage!

It’s safe to say that CIRCUS ANIMAL is all you’ll need this Valentine’s Day!


*Processed in a facility that also works with peanuts, wheat, dairy, and soy.*

*If brownies are desired to arrive on a specific date, please order at least a week in advance due to the influx of orders.*


Refrigerate upon arrival. Keep them in the refrigerator so they stay intact. You can either take them out and either eat cold or warm them up in the microwave for 5-10 seconds if you want them to taste as if they came right out of the oven.

Not planning on eating within 7 days upon arrival? Throw them in the freezer to ensure their moistness. Let them defrost when ready to be consumed.

*There are no refunds or returns*

Customer Reviews

Based on 41 reviews

These things are seriously amazing!!


Product was great I'm more of a blondie guy I gave the brownies to my lady we both enjoy them thank you

Tracy Vranic

I sent these to my son at college and he thought they were amazing! Especially the cookie one with sprinkles!

Zachary Schapekahm
Very delicious and very happy!

These brownies were amazing and tasted great even after freezing and reheating. I have to admit I placed an order for another four brownies because they were so good!

Vuyani Sithole
Balanced Brownies

The brownies were really good. What I like is how balanced they are. Typically brownies are really rich and overly sweet. These were not, they are sweet but not too sweet. So I was able to eat them without stopping. Perfectly balanced brownies that I throughly enjoyed.