Γ
This dialog asks for your consent. Please review and make your choice.

OrderProtect

Adding Order Protect to your order protects your order from loss in transit or theft. Please review our terms and conditions for more details.

protect from loss or theft by deselecting, we are not liable for lost or stolen packages

Skip to content

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Have an account?

Log in to check out faster.

Your cart

Loading...

Estimated total

$0.00 USD

Taxes, discounts and shipping calculated at checkout.

🫐 Muffin Madness is LIVE! Celebrate with us for National Blueberry Muffin Day!—plus FREE shipping on all domestic orders over $100! 🚚

  • Home
  • Brownies
  • Cookies
  • The Classics
  • Brownie Cakes
  • Save With Our Bundles!
  • About Us
Log in

Country/region

  • Canada CAD $
  • Germany EUR €
  • United Arab Emirates AED د.إ
  • United States USD $
  • Afghanistan AFN ؋
  • Åland Islands EUR €
  • Albania ALL L
  • Algeria DZD د.ج
  • Andorra EUR €
  • Angola USD $
  • Anguilla XCD $
  • Antigua & Barbuda XCD $
  • Argentina USD $
  • Armenia AMD դր.
  • Aruba AWG ƒ
  • Ascension Island SHP £
  • Australia AUD $
  • Austria EUR €
  • Azerbaijan AZN ₼
  • Bahamas BSD $
  • Bahrain USD $
  • Bangladesh BDT ৳
  • Barbados BBD $
  • Belarus USD $
  • Belgium EUR €
  • Belize BZD $
  • Benin XOF Fr
  • Bermuda USD $
  • Bhutan USD $
  • Bolivia BOB Bs.
  • Bosnia & Herzegovina BAM КМ
  • Botswana BWP P
  • Brazil USD $
  • British Indian Ocean Territory USD $
  • British Virgin Islands USD $
  • Brunei BND $
  • Bulgaria BGN лв.
  • Burkina Faso XOF Fr
  • Burundi BIF Fr
  • Cambodia KHR ៛
  • Cameroon XAF CFA
  • Canada CAD $
  • Cape Verde CVE $
  • Caribbean Netherlands USD $
  • Cayman Islands KYD $
  • Central African Republic XAF CFA
  • Chad XAF CFA
  • Chile USD $
  • China CNY ¥
  • Christmas Island AUD $
  • Cocos (Keeling) Islands AUD $
  • Colombia USD $
  • Comoros KMF Fr
  • Congo - Brazzaville XAF CFA
  • Congo - Kinshasa CDF Fr
  • Cook Islands NZD $
  • Costa Rica CRC ₡
  • Côte d’Ivoire XOF Fr
  • Croatia EUR €
  • Curaçao ANG ƒ
  • Cyprus EUR €
  • Czechia CZK Kč
  • Denmark DKK kr.
  • Djibouti DJF Fdj
  • Dominica XCD $
  • Dominican Republic DOP $
  • Ecuador USD $
  • Egypt EGP ج.م
  • El Salvador USD $
  • Equatorial Guinea XAF CFA
  • Eritrea USD $
  • Estonia EUR €
  • Eswatini USD $
  • Ethiopia ETB Br
  • Falkland Islands FKP £
  • Faroe Islands DKK kr.
  • Fiji FJD $
  • Finland EUR €
  • France EUR €
  • French Guiana EUR €
  • French Polynesia XPF Fr
  • French Southern Territories EUR €
  • Gabon XOF Fr
  • Gambia GMD D
  • Georgia USD $
  • Germany EUR €
  • Ghana USD $
  • Gibraltar GBP £
  • Greece EUR €
  • Greenland DKK kr.
  • Grenada XCD $
  • Guadeloupe EUR €
  • Guatemala GTQ Q
  • Guernsey GBP £
  • Guinea GNF Fr
  • Guinea-Bissau XOF Fr
  • Guyana GYD $
  • Haiti USD $
  • Honduras HNL L
  • Hong Kong SAR HKD $
  • Hungary HUF Ft
  • Iceland ISK kr
  • India INR ₹
  • Indonesia IDR Rp
  • Iraq USD $
  • Ireland EUR €
  • Isle of Man GBP £
  • Israel ILS ₪
  • Italy EUR €
  • Jamaica JMD $
  • Japan JPY ¥
  • Jersey USD $
  • Jordan USD $
  • Kazakhstan KZT ₸
  • Kenya KES KSh
  • Kiribati USD $
  • Kosovo EUR €
  • Kuwait USD $
  • Kyrgyzstan KGS som
  • Laos LAK ₭
  • Latvia EUR €
  • Lebanon LBP ل.ل
  • Lesotho USD $
  • Liberia USD $
  • Libya USD $
  • Liechtenstein CHF CHF
  • Lithuania EUR €
  • Luxembourg EUR €
  • Macao SAR MOP P
  • Madagascar USD $
  • Malawi MWK MK
  • Malaysia MYR RM
  • Maldives MVR MVR
  • Mali XOF Fr
  • Malta EUR €
  • Martinique EUR €
  • Mauritania USD $
  • Mauritius MUR ₨
  • Mayotte EUR €
  • Mexico USD $
  • Moldova MDL L
  • Monaco EUR €
  • Mongolia MNT ₮
  • Montenegro EUR €
  • Montserrat XCD $
  • Morocco MAD د.م.
  • Mozambique USD $
  • Myanmar (Burma) MMK K
  • Namibia USD $
  • Nauru AUD $
  • Nepal NPR Rs.
  • Netherlands EUR €
  • New Caledonia XPF Fr
  • New Zealand NZD $
  • Nicaragua NIO C$
  • Niger XOF Fr
  • Nigeria NGN ₦
  • Niue NZD $
  • Norfolk Island AUD $
  • North Macedonia MKD ден
  • Norway USD $
  • Oman USD $
  • Pakistan PKR ₨
  • Palestinian Territories ILS ₪
  • Panama USD $
  • Papua New Guinea PGK K
  • Paraguay PYG ₲
  • Peru PEN S/
  • Philippines PHP ₱
  • Pitcairn Islands NZD $
  • Poland PLN zł
  • Portugal EUR €
  • Qatar QAR ر.ق
  • Réunion EUR €
  • Romania RON Lei
  • Russia USD $
  • Rwanda RWF FRw
  • Samoa WST T
  • San Marino EUR €
  • São Tomé & Príncipe STD Db
  • Saudi Arabia SAR ر.س
  • Senegal XOF Fr
  • Serbia RSD РСД
  • Seychelles USD $
  • Sierra Leone SLL Le
  • Singapore SGD $
  • Sint Maarten ANG ƒ
  • Slovakia EUR €
  • Slovenia EUR €
  • Solomon Islands SBD $
  • Somalia USD $
  • South Africa USD $
  • South Georgia & South Sandwich Islands GBP £
  • South Korea KRW ₩
  • South Sudan USD $
  • Spain EUR €
  • Sri Lanka LKR ₨
  • St. Barthélemy EUR €
  • St. Helena SHP £
  • St. Kitts & Nevis XCD $
  • St. Lucia XCD $
  • St. Martin EUR €
  • St. Pierre & Miquelon EUR €
  • St. Vincent & Grenadines XCD $
  • Sudan USD $
  • Suriname USD $
  • Svalbard & Jan Mayen USD $
  • Sweden SEK kr
  • Switzerland CHF CHF
  • Taiwan TWD $
  • Tajikistan TJS ЅМ
  • Tanzania TZS Sh
  • Thailand THB ฿
  • Timor-Leste USD $
  • Togo XOF Fr
  • Tokelau NZD $
  • Tonga TOP T$
  • Trinidad & Tobago TTD $
  • Tristan da Cunha GBP £
  • Tunisia USD $
  • Türkiye USD $
  • Turkmenistan USD $
  • Turks & Caicos Islands USD $
  • Tuvalu AUD $
  • U.S. Outlying Islands USD $
  • Uganda UGX USh
  • Ukraine UAH ₴
  • United Arab Emirates AED د.إ
  • United Kingdom GBP £
  • United States USD $
  • Uruguay UYU $U
  • Uzbekistan UZS so'm
  • Vanuatu VUV Vt
  • Vatican City EUR €
  • Venezuela USD $
  • Vietnam VND ₫
  • Wallis & Futuna XPF Fr
  • Western Sahara MAD د.م.
  • Yemen YER ﷼
  • Zambia USD $
  • Zimbabwe USD $
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • SHOP BROWNIES
  • THE CLASSICS
  • BROWNIE CAKES
Buckeye Brownies
Cart

    FAQ

    FAQS
  • I paid for 2 day shipping, but I have not received my order yet. How Come?


    All orders can take anywhere from 5-7 days to be BAKED FRESH prior to shipped. Upon being baked, it will be shipped the following day to ensure it’s the highest quality. As a small business, it takes us a few days to be able to back each and every other fresh prior to shipping it out.

  • How long does shipping take?

    Shipping itself will depend on which option you purchase at checkout. We offer 1, 2 and 3 day shipping options. But remember, it can take us 4-7 days to bake each order fresh prior to shipment.

  • How long do your brownies last during shipment?

    Our brownies have a shelf life of up to 10 days in transit due to their unique 3 layered design and thickness. Although they can arrive a little melted, do not worry! Simply put them in the fridge upon arrival and they’ll be good to go!

  • Can I pickup an order at your location?

    Absolutely! If you would like to pickup your order in Akron, OH, please order online accordingly and then send a follow up email to zack@buckeyebrownies.com to request pickup. We will then coordinate from there. Shipping will be refunded upon pickup.

  • Why are my brownies different sizes and shapes?

    All of our brownies are hand cut during packaging which can cause them to be slightly different sizes due to human error. All are always over a 1/2 lb. each.

  • Why are my brownies taking longer to be delivered than normal?

    Every now and then, Shipping carriers can have delays due to a decrease in staff, trucking issues or simply misplacing your package. Unfortunately, these are out of our control. If you do not get your order after a full week after it’s has been shipped out, please contact zack@buckeyebrownies.com

  • What are the macros or nutrition facts for your products?

    We do not provide the nutrition facts for any our products. Why? Because Each and every batch varies so much that the macros provided would be inaccurate and per the FDA, it is illegal to falsely claim nutritional content on any food. We do estimate that each full brownie is about 1000 calories on average.

  • Do your Brownies contain any protein?

    Unfortunately they do not! Our brownies are gooey and gourmet and are not considered healthy by any means! They are a treat to indulge in!

  • Do you have Gluten Free products?

    Yes! However, Our Gluten Free brownies are NOT Gluten certified as we do bake in a facility that processes wheat.

  • Do you ship over seas?

    Yes we have shipped to over 30 countries across the World.

  • Can they be frozen?

    Absolutely! They can be frozen up to 3 months.

  • Can I preorder?

    Unless it’s a bulk order, unfortunately no. How our ordering works is that it is first come first serve. Once your order is placed than your order is in line and will be fulfilled once we get to it. All orders can take 4-7 days to be baked fresh prior to shipment.

  • Where do you guys bake your product?

    We bake our product in an ODA approved private 5000 sf commercial bakery in Akron, OH.

  • Do you offer gift cards?

    Yes we do. Click this link to get yours!

  • Do you sell wholesale?

    Yes we do! For wholesale inquiries send an email to zack@buckeyebrownies.com.

  • What all comes with the Pick Two?

    Pick Two comes with 4 brownies where you will get 2 and 2 of whichever two flavors of your choice. This is only limited to our original flavors.

  • When do you come out with new flavors?

    At the start of every month, we come out with a new “Monthly Pack”.

  • Can I customize a box?

    Yes, when we provide our build your box option, you can select that and choose any 4 brownies of your choice that are available at that time. This only launches for one week out of every month, typically the last week that the limited edition flavors are available.

  • As an international customer, are there any more Fees I might expect when ordering my brownies?

    Yes! Mainly with Canadian customers, there can be an import tax that is required to be paid prior to delivery. This is NOT included in your shipping costs as this is additional and out of our control. If you’d like a refund prior to shipment. Please reach out.

SIGN UP FOR UPDATES

Promotions, new products and sales. Directly to your inbox.

  • About Us
  • Shop
  • Ingredients
  • Shipping Policy
  • Refund Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Subscription Service Agreement
  • Manage Subscription
Payment methods
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
© 2025 Buckeye Brownies. Proudly designed by NinetySix Design Studio & 11 Equities.
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Opens in a new window.