🔥 YOU ASKED. WE ANSWERED. 🍫
We took 16 of our top-selling flavors of 2025 and let you decide. After thousands of votes, only FOUR could take the crown. Say hello to the flavors you couldn’t stop talking about—the Fan Favorite Box. 👑
Each box includes Cookie Monster 🍪, Churro Caramel Cream 🍯, PB Paradise 🥜, and Pebbles & Cream 🍓, delivering the perfect mix of bold, nostalgic, and insanely crave-worthy flavors. 🤤
If you’ve been thinking about trying Buckeye Brownies, this is the box to start with.
⏳ Only available until February 2nd—stock up before these fan favorites disappear! 🎉🍫
Couldn't load pickup availability
FREE SHIPPING OVER $100
BAKED FRESH IN AKRON, OH
LIMITED EDITION FLAVORS
Blondie base, Layered with strawberry poptart, topped with our fruity pebble infused strawberry milk cookie dough, Vanilla frosting drizzle after the bake
Brownie base, chips ahoy and oreos in middle, white chip loaded cookie monster cookie dough, oreo crumb topping and blue vanilla frosting drizzle
Blondie base, Layered with Brown Sugar poptart, Topped with our Churro Caramel chip cookie dough. Perfected with Vanilla Ganache and Cinnamon Sugar
Brownie base, layered with PB Oreos, Topped with Reeses Infused Chocolate PB Chip cookie dough, More Reeses Pieces and PB Cup after the bake
We bake our product in an ODA approved private 5000 sf commercial bakery in Akron, OH.
Shipping itself will depend on which option you purchase at checkout. We offer 1, 2 and 3 day shipping options. But remember, it can take us 4-7 days to bake each order fresh prior to shipment.
Our brownies have a shelf life of up to 10 days in transit due to their unique 3 layered design and thickness. Although they can arrive a little melted, do not worry! Simply put them in the fridge upon arrival and they’ll be good to go!
Absolutely! If you would like to pickup your order in Akron, OH, please order online accordingly and then send a follow up email to zack@buckeyebrownies.com to request pickup. We will then coordinate from there. Shipping will be refunded upon pickup.
All of our brownies are hand cut during packaging which can cause them to be slightly different sizes due to human error. All are always over a 1/2 lb. each.
Every now and then, Shipping carriers can have delays due to a decrease in staff, trucking issues or simply misplacing your package. Unfortunately, these are out of our control. If you do not get your order after a full week after it’s has been shipped out, please contact zack@buckeyebrownies.com
We do not provide the nutrition facts for any our products. Why? Because Each and every batch varies so much that the macros provided would be inaccurate and per the FDA, it is illegal to falsely claim nutritional content on any food. We do estimate that each full brownie is about 1000 calories on average.
Yes! However, Our Gluten Free brownies are NOT Gluten certified as we do bake in a facility that processes wheat.
Yes we have shipped to over 30 countries across the World.
Absolutely! They can be frozen up to 3 months.
Buckeye Brownies strive to provide you with the most unique and gourmet, ½ lb brownies and blondies on the market today. Not only are these treats out of this world, but we bake them with three layers of goodness to ensure they’re always packed with flavor.
Our delicious desserts are always baked to order to ensure you’re receiving only the freshest and highest quality batch each and every time. Using all natural and nutrient dense ingredients such as grass-fed butter, extra virgin olive oil, cane sugar and much more, our brownies are definitely a must try.
