The Fantastic Four Pack | Buckeye Brownies
Buckeye Brownies

Fantastic Four Pack

Sale price Price $28.00 Regular price Unit price  per 

With this pack, you will get the opportunity to try each of our four flagship flavors that we will be selling year-round, The MVP, Mr. Buckeye, The Gift, and Snickerdoodle and Chill. Each brownie is approximately 4”x4”x2”.


He’s known for always putting the team on his back, bringing above and beyond effort day in and day out and always being able to put a smile on people’s faces, meet The MVP.

This cookies and cream based brownie starts with our fudge brownie base which is then layered with chocolate creme sandwich cookies to give you a little crunch.

It is then topped with our homemade cookies and cream cookie dough infused with white chocolate and chocolate chips.

But we couldn’t stop there, so we topped everything with some more cookies and chocolate chips to really express how valuable this bad boy really is.

He’s not just a player, he’s The MVP.

Order Brownies Online - Buckeye Brownies



Not all heroes wear capes! Because whoever decided to combine chocolate with peanut butter is an absolute genius! Meet, Mr Buckeye.

This decadent dessert first starts with our fudge brownie base which is then layered with none other than some of the best peanut butter cookies on the market, Nutter Butters.

We then topped it all with our homemade Reeses Pieces cookie dough. Although it looked great, it didn’t reach the standard yet.

This is why we sprinkled some more Reeses Pieces on top and added another peanut butter cookie to really balance out that chocolate peanut butter ratio.

So If your heart melts at all things chocolate-peanut butter, we can promise that this is the brownie for you!

Order Brownies Online - Buckeye Brownies



She’s simple, she’s sweet and tastes much better than your average cupcake treat, introducing The Gift.

This colorful dessert first starts with our soft blondie base which is then topped with a frosted cupcake toaster pastry.

To make this gift even sweeter, we then added a top layer of sugar cookie dough and loaded it up with rainbow sprinkles.

Let’s just say this will be the only gift you’ll be asking for during the next holiday!

Order Brownies Online - Buckeye Brownies



Forget about Netflix and meet, Snickerdoodle and Chill, the only sweet treat that is guaranteed to end your night the way you predicted.

This beauty starts out with our buttery blondie base which is then blanketed with a layer of vanilla creme sandwich cookies.

We then topped it all with our homemade snickerdoodle cookie dough and baked it to perfection.

After the bake, we top this gem with some white chocolate chips, a cream cheese frosting drizzle and sprinkle some turbinado cane sugar to finish it off.

We can promise this will be the only thing you wanna dive into on those lonely nights.

Order Brownies Online - Buckeye Brownies


*Processed in a facility that also works with peanuts, wheat, dairy, and soy.*

*If brownies are desired to arrive on a specific date, please order at least a week in advance due to the influx of orders.*


Refrigerate upon arrival. Keep them in the refrigerator so they stay intact. You can either take them out and either eat cold or warm them up in the microwave for 5-10 seconds if you want them to taste as if they came right out of the oven.

Not planning on eating within 7 days upon arrival? Throw them in the freezer to ensure their moistness. Let them defrost when ready to be consumed.

*There are no refunds or returns*


Shop Brownies Online Here

Customer Reviews

Based on 40 reviews
Michele Taylor
September box was delicious

The September brownie box was delicious. My favorite was the peanut 🥜 butter one. My second favorite was the snickerdoodle. I highly recommend and might order to give out as gifts. The packaging was done very well. They arrived fresh and I loved the instructions that came with them. Keep up the excellent work.

Chelsea Federer
So good

Great brownies, fast shipping, gather 5 of your closest friends to help you eat this delicious diabetes loaf of no regrets.

Kevin Godoy
Worth the purchase

If you want your taste buds to straight up get laid, these brownies are for you. Absolutely delicious!

Crystal Lawhon

I heated these brownies and then I even ate them after I froze them. They were great both ways!!! Loved them aol but the Reece’s was my favorite.

Paul Dower
Filled with flavor

The brownies were insane. There was multiple flavors in one. The size was perfect. I cut up the brownie in quarters and it gave me a good snack throughout my day.